Philanthropy & Impact
CSR, family giving and impact capital, paid for outcomes rather than spend.
How we see it
India has an unusual institution in Section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013, which requires companies above set thresholds to spend a share of their average net profit on causes listed in Schedule VII. The result is a large and predictable annual flow of money that few countries have. It has funded schools, health facilities, water and skills programmes at scale. What it has not reliably produced is a record of changed outcomes, because the rule counts what was spent, and spending is easy to show while gains in learning, health and income are slow to appear.
Family philanthropy and endowments are the other source, and they behave differently. A family foundation can hold a ten-year view, fund evaluation and tolerate failure, which companies bound by annual reporting often cannot. Blended finance and outcomes-based instruments try to combine these strengths: a funder pays for results, an investor carries the early risk and an implementation partner delivers. Early impact bonds in India, in girls' schooling and in maternal and newborn health in Rajasthan, showed the idea can work and how heavy the transaction costs are.
Implementation partners are the weakest link and the most important one. NGOs and delivery organisations often run on short grants with tight limits on overheads, which leaves little room to build systems, pay staff well or measure results. We see the gap between giving and outcomes as a capacity gap more than a motivation gap. Aligning with the national missions in health, education, skills, water and climate adaptation lets private money strengthen programmes that already reach scale instead of building parallel ones.
Why now
CSR has matured. Rules revised in 2021 recognised multi-year ongoing projects, required unspent funds to be held in dedicated accounts and introduced impact assessment for larger projects of larger companies. Boards now have both a legal reason and a practical opening to think beyond the financial year. The Social Stock Exchange framework from SEBI offers another route to raise and report funding for non-profits.
The national missions provide a shared target. Programmes such as the Jal Jeevan Mission, NIPUN Bharat for early reading and numeracy, and the Aspirational Districts Programme publish indicators that private funders can align to. Where giving is tied to such indicators, it becomes easier to ask whether anything changed, and whether it would have changed anyway. Several of these programmes also report district-level data, which makes comparison possible.
Trends we follow
CSR moves from assets to multi-year programmes
Companies are beginning to use the ongoing-project provision to commit across several years, and to ask partners for results instead of completion certificates. The shift is slow because boards, auditors and managers are used to annual cycles and visible assets. We follow which companies change their approval process, and whether the dedicated unspent-funds account pushes plans toward longer horizons.
Outcomes-based finance settles into a few repeatable designs
Impact bonds and outcome funds are expensive to design, and early deals relied on foundations to underwrite them. Pooled outcome funds, standard contracts and government as an outcome payer could lower the cost. We follow which sectors, such as education, maternal health and employment, have outcomes that can be measured cheaply and attributed with credibility.
Evaluation moves inside the programme
Randomised trials, administrative data and third-party assessment are more common, and the 2021 CSR rules asked for impact assessment on larger projects. Measurement costs money and is often resisted by implementers who fear losing funding. Programmes that agree indicators and a baseline at the start, and publish results including disappointing ones, build knowledge that others can use.
Family offices professionalise giving
A new generation of family wealth is hiring staff, setting multi-year strategies and co-funding with peers. Donor collaboratives pool money around a shared problem, such as foundational learning or urban water. We look at how family capital can take risks that companies cannot, and how it connects to government programmes that reach scale.
Climate adaptation becomes a giving priority
Heat, floods and water stress hit the poorest first, and adaptation has fewer natural funders than mitigation. Watershed work, heat action plans, flood-resilient housing, crop insurance and early warning are areas where philanthropic and CSR money can sit beside public programmes. The measurement challenge is that success means a loss that did not happen.
What we look for
- We look for funders willing to commit for five years or more and to pay for measurement and for the core costs of the organisations they back.
- We look for implementation partners with a record of delivering at district scale and of working inside government programmes, not beside them.
- We look for outcome measures that a sceptic would accept, with a baseline, a comparison and a published result.
- We look for business models in health, education, skills and water where a social outcome and a paying customer, often the government, can coexist.
- We look for family and corporate donors who will publish what did not work.
Questions we are working on
- How should a board approve CSR on a five-year outcome basis when reporting is still done by financial year?
- Which social outcomes in India can be measured cheaply enough to pay for?
- How can government pay for outcomes that a private partner delivers, within procurement and audit rules?
- What does an implementation partner need, beyond a project grant, to become a durable institution?
Writing on philanthropy & impact
Part of 2 cross-cutting trends on the interests page.