Generational

Media

Why India Inc. and the public sector need better conversations

Departments and firms describe the same stalled project differently, and business media rarely covers delivery. Convening can close that gap.

India Inc. and the public sector spend much of their time on the same problems, such as land, power, approvals, procurement and payments, and very little of it in the same room. A government department and a private firm can describe one stalled project in ways that share almost no facts. We think structured conversation between them is infrastructure, and the business media most readers rely on is not set up to provide it.

Two accounts of the same project

A department speaks in file notings, rules, audit objections, sanctioned budgets and the sequence of approvals. A firm speaks in working capital, milestones, penalties and the cost of financing. Both accounts are accurate inside their own frame. Take a payment held up pending a certificate. The department sees compliance with a procurement rule. The firm sees receivables ageing by the week and a lender asking questions.

Without a shared fact base, such as which clearance was pending, for how long and on whose desk, each side retreats to its own version. Each version is then repeated to colleagues, to lenders and to the press, and it hardens. The disagreement stops being about the project and becomes about who is to blame.

Highways offer an example. The shift from build-operate-transfer toll concessions to the hybrid annuity model followed a period of stress for developers and lenders. The lessons were learned in contracts and courtrooms more than in open forums, which meant the people drafting the next contract and the people bidding for it often reached the same conclusion separately and late.

What a good convening does

A convening is more than a panel. Done well, it changes what the participants know when they leave. We would hold it to four tests.

  • It establishes shared facts: a common timeline for a project or a rule, with real dates and owners, before anyone argues about it.
  • It surfaces early signals on policy, such as draft rules, consultation papers and the reasoning behind them, while changes are still cheap to make.
  • It holds honest post-mortems on projects that failed or stalled, with the people who ran them, so that the lesson is about mechanism and not blame.
  • It puts officials and executives together at the level where decisions are actually taken, not only where speeches are made.

The third test is the hardest and the most useful. The public sector rarely publishes why a project failed, and private firms rarely say, for commercial and legal reasons. The result is that the same errors repeat: land acquisition timelines that were too optimistic, interface risk between contractors that nobody owned, payment and tariff assumptions that broke under stress. A well-documented failure teaches more than a well-staged success, and it costs the next project nothing.

Announcements are easy to report. Delivery is where the information is.

Why business media covers markets and not delivery

Indian business media follows its audience and its revenue, and both sit with listed companies, quarterly results, share prices, deal announcements and the Budget. Those stories are fast, they have a clear reader and they attach to a ticker. A story on whether a procurement process actually works, or whether a ministry and a contractor can resolve an interface dispute, is slower, needs domain knowledge and attaches to nothing that trades.

Coverage of the public sector has a similar bias. It is full of policy announcements and thin on implementation. Announcements are easy to report because they arrive as documents. Follow-through has to be pieced together from many offices over many months. Sourcing adds a further limit: serving officials usually cannot speak on the record about a live matter, so a reporter with a deadline will often have nothing to write with.

A format that lets officials discuss process, as opposed to politics, closes part of that gap. They can explain how a clearance moves, why a rule was drafted as it was and where a scheme runs into trouble, without commenting on any minister or any pending case. Executives, for their part, can describe how long things took and what they cost without naming a counterparty in a dispute.

The reasoning behind a media platform for delivery

India Media Network is our platform for conversations and convenings about India Inc. and the public sector. The reasoning behind it is simple. A country trying to build at the pace India intends needs the people who commission work and the people who deliver it to share facts, and few outlets are built for that. We would rather add one that is.

There is an obvious open problem, and we would rather state it than hide it. We do not yet know how to measure whether a convening changed a decision. Attendance and attention are easy to count and tell very little. The better test is whether a rule was drafted differently, a contract clause was written differently, or a failure was not repeated. We expect that evidence to be slow and anecdotal at first, and we will treat it with suspicion until it is not.

More from Media