Decision quality in India's economy depends on analysis that arrives early and in a form someone can act on, and the private sector buys too little of it. We treat that analysis as infrastructure: a shared, maintained capacity beneath decisions about where to source, where to build, whom to lend to and how to respond when another country changes its rules. Government produces a great deal of it. Companies mostly buy it after the event. A trustworthy civilian analytic capacity, built on public sources and disclosed methods, would fill the space between.
What government already does, and what it cannot share
Inside government, analysis is substantial. Ministries employ economic advisers, the Reserve Bank publishes research and data, NITI Aayog produces policy studies, and the PM Gati Shakti National Master Plan brings geospatial layers from many departments onto one platform so that railway, road and utility projects can be planned together. Much of this work is good and much of it is closed, for sound reasons. Some of it concerns national security. Some of it is simply not written for outsiders. A private manufacturer deciding on a second source for a component cannot expect a ministry to say what is coming.
Official statistics also arrive on a schedule. A customs release, a quarterly national account or a gazette notification confirms what was already moving. Early signals sit elsewhere: in ship movements, in a draft rule put out for comment, in a power plant's fuel stock, in a supplier's filings.
What the private sector buys, and what it skips
Indian firms do buy analysis, but in a pattern that undervalues it. A consulting report follows a shock. A risk team is staffed during a crisis and trimmed afterwards. Counterparty checks are done at signing and not repeated. Compare how the same firms treat finance or legal departments: a continuing cost, justified by what it prevents. Analysis rarely gets that status because its value is invisible when it works. A supply disruption that never occurred does not appear in a quarterly result.
The costs show up in recent history. Indian pharmaceutical makers learned how far they depended on imported active ingredients when supply tightened in 2020. Importers and exporters redrew routes and contracts when shipping was diverted away from the Red Sea. In both cases the data on dependence and routing existed beforehand. What was missing was someone whose standing job was to read it and say what it meant.
Early warning is a standing job, and it fails when it is treated as an occasional project.
What a trustworthy civilian capacity looks like
We would hold such a capacity to a short list of standards.
- Sources are lawful and disclosed: public records, licensed commercial data, satellite and ship-tracking feeds and filings, with no collection that breaches anyone's privacy.
- Facts are separated from judgments, and every judgment carries a stated level of confidence.
- Methods can be reviewed by someone who did not produce the analysis, and past calls are checked against what happened.
- Personal data is handled within the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, and used only for a stated purpose.
- The client receives a recommendation and a date by which to act, in addition to a description.
These are ordinary professional rules, close to those that govern audit and credit rating, and India already has institutions that can make them credible: auditors, rating agencies and research bodies. The same standards keep the work on the right side of a line. This is defensive and commercial analysis of risks to one's own supply chain, money and projects. It does not extend to the activities of governments or individuals, and a firm that drifts there deserves to lose its clients.
Where we expect disagreement
Two objections are fair. The first is that this work belongs to the state, and private actors will duplicate or distort it. We disagree. Government analysis serves government decisions, and companies facing commercial risk need their own. A civilian layer built on open and licensed data takes nothing from the state and spares it repeated requests for information from industry. The second objection is that private analysis can be sold as certainty. That risk is real, and it is the reason for the standards above and for a market in which buyers can compare track records.
Geospatial data is where the question is sharpest. India's liberalised geospatial guidelines of 2021 and the National Geospatial Policy opened mapping data to Indian firms, and IN-SPACe is widening private access to space capacity. What the market lacks is the habit of buying analysis from these sources continuously. We are watching whether a few early buyers, such as lenders, large manufacturers and infrastructure operators, begin to hold standing analytic contracts, and whether the sellers publish how often they were right.