Generational

Media

Economic diplomacy needs a delivery arm

Trade agreements and supply chain partnerships pay off only when firms can use them, which takes practical help on origin, standards, finance, logistics.

Economic diplomacy produces agreements, but agreements only pay off when firms can use them, and that takes a delivery arm: a set of practical services that turns a negotiated opening into an order. India has put real effort into trade agreements and supply chain partnerships. The next gain is less in the negotiating room than in the exporter’s office, where a small firm has to decide whether the paperwork for a lower tariff is worth the trouble.

A signed agreement is where the work starts

A trade agreement lowers tariffs on listed goods, but only for goods that qualify. Qualifying is decided by rules of origin, which require an exporter to show that enough of a product’s value was added within the partner countries. That means records of inputs, supplier declarations and a certificate for each consignment. A large firm has staff for this. A small manufacturer of auto components or garments often does not, and may decide to ship without claiming the preference. The tariff cut then exists in the treaty and not in the price.

Standards add a second wall. A buyer abroad may require tests, certifications or sanitary and plant-health clearances that the exporter’s home laboratories are not recognised to perform. Finance and logistics add more: a first-time exporter needs credit, insurance against non-payment and a freight route that does not eat the margin the tariff cut created. India has concluded agreements in recent years with partners including the UAE, Australia and the EFTA states. How much of each agreement is used, by which products and by firms of which size, is the real test, and it is rarely discussed.

What a delivery arm does

It need not be a new bureaucracy. The pieces already exist. Commercial staff in Indian missions abroad know buyers and local rules. Export promotion councils know their sectors. The Directorate General of Foreign Trade handles export rules and certificates of origin at home. EXIM Bank finances exports and overseas projects, and ECGC insures exporters against non-payment. Invest India courts foreign investment. The trouble is that these bodies sit in different ministries, keep their own relationships and rarely present one face to a firm.

Our position is that every priority market should have a single point of contact for firms, with the authority to coordinate across those bodies. For a given product it should answer four questions: what does the agreement give me, what do I need to prove, who tests and certifies, and who can finance and ship. It should also keep a list of vetted local importers, distributors and lawyers, since the most common reason a first export fails is a bad local partner.

A tariff concession is a licence to compete, and a firm still has to turn up with the paperwork, the credit and a buyer.

Credit lines, partnerships and a multi-aligned stance

India also extends development finance, mainly through Lines of Credit that EXIM Bank administers on behalf of the Government of India, and through development partnership projects handled by the Ministry of External Affairs. These credits typically carry a requirement that a portion of goods and services come from Indian suppliers. Done well, they give Indian contractors, equipment makers and consultants a first foothold in a market, and a record that can win later commercial work. Done poorly, they leave a stalled project, an unpaid contractor and a partner who remembers.

The difference lies in what follows the handover. A power line or a rail coach supplied under a credit line is followed by spares, maintenance and training, and those are repeat revenue for the Indian firms involved. We would link credit approval to a plan for that afterlife, so that a one-time project becomes a lasting commercial relationship. Delays in approval and payment are the other risk, and they fall hardest on small suppliers.

India’s multi-alignment is easiest to understand in this light. It trades, invests and buys defence equipment, energy and technology from many partners, and does not accept that a firm must pick a bloc. For a business, this is a practical stance with practical consequences. It means India can offer itself as a supplier and a market to several partners at once, and that its firms should plan for sourcing and selling in more than one direction. The stance is only credible when firms can actually deliver in each direction.

What we are watching is published utilisation data: for each agreement, the share of eligible exports that actually claim the preference, broken down by product and firm size. It would show where the delivery arm is needed most. The open problem is who pays for the services that small exporters cannot buy for themselves.

More from Media