Generational

Media

Culture is an economy, and India under-builds for it

Tourism, crafts, food and film employ many Indians, yet public effort goes to monuments and campaigns instead of the services that make visits pay.

Culture is one of India’s most employment-dense sectors, and the country builds too little of what turns it into income. Public effort goes into monuments, festivals and advertising campaigns. Visitors, who decide whether a place earns anything, need a ride, a clean room, a safe walk, someone to explain what they are looking at, and a reason to spend money before they leave. Our view is that spending should move from marquee assets to the connecting services, and should be judged by local income, not footfall.

Where the jobs are

Most travel in India is by Indians, within India, by a wide margin. Families go to temples and shrines on long-established pilgrimage routes, to hill towns, to coasts, to a village wedding that doubles as a holiday. That demand is large, steady and not very sensitive to global shocks. It is also labour-intensive in a useful way. A visitor creates work for drivers, cooks, guides, homestay hosts, flower sellers, porters and craftspeople, and the capital needed per job is small compared with most industries.

The same is true of crafts, handloom and regional food, and of film and music. These sectors employ many people, often informally and often in small towns, and their weak point is rarely skill. It is reaching a buyer at a fair price, again and again. A weaver with a good product and no route to a customer earns little. A town with a well-known dish and no clean place to eat it loses the diner to the next town.

What visitors need and what gets built

Think about the trip as a chain. A visitor must reach the town, find a room at a fair price, get from the room to the site, feel safe, understand what they see, and find something worth buying. Each link has to hold, and the weakest one decides the experience. What public programmes tend to build is the single most visible link: a restored fort, a gateway, a plaza, a campaign with a slogan.

The schemes themselves are sensible. Swadesh Darshan, run by the Ministry of Tourism, funds themed circuits so that places linked by a story or a route are developed together. PRASHAD, the scheme for pilgrimage and heritage destinations, pays for amenities where large numbers of devotees arrive. Both put money into real facilities. The difficulty comes after the inauguration. Who runs the visitor centre? Who keeps the toilets clean in the second year? Who runs the shuttle between the station and the shrine? An asset with no operator decays, and a circuit with a single polished site and no bed within an hour’s drive is not a circuit.

A monument is a cost until someone is paid to look after the visitor who comes to see it.

Interpretation is the most neglected link. A fort or temple seen without a guide, clear signs in several languages or any account of why it matters is a twenty-minute stop, not a day’s outing. Trained local guides, small museums and well-told stories raise the time visitors stay, and with it the spending. Lodging is the second gap: the middle of the market, simple hotels and registered homestays, is hard to finance for small operators who lack collateral. Better to back dozens of such operators than one large resort.

So our position is plain. Public money should buy the operator layer: concessions to run transport, lodging and visitor services under performance terms, credit for small hosts, and training for local guides. Success should be counted in nights stayed and income earned by local households, not in the number of people who walked past.

Culture as soft power

India’s cultural reach abroad is wide: yoga, cuisine, cinema, music, textiles, a large diaspora and cultural centres run under the Indian Council for Cultural Relations. But influence of this kind is carried by things people can buy, watch, eat and visit. A restaurant makes friends for a country in a way a brochure cannot. Soft power therefore rests on a working domestic industry. A craft sector with repeat buyers exports well. A tourism sector that treats visitors properly gets recommended.

This links culture to diplomacy in a practical way. Film distribution, craft exports, festivals and food businesses abroad are commercial activities that also carry a country’s image. Diplomats can open the door, but only firms that deliver on quality and price will keep it open.

What we are watching is whether circuit schemes begin to write operator contracts with performance terms and to publish results on visitor nights and local income. The open problem is measurement: most craft and homestay earnings are informal and unrecorded, so the sector’s real scale, and the true return on public spending, is still partly unseen.

More from Media