Generational

Media

Energy security is national security: what India has to build

India's energy risk is import dependence in fuels and minerals, and build order matters: grid and storage first, then processing, then hydrogen.

India's energy security problem is an import-dependence problem, and it has three layers: the fuels the country buys abroad, the minerals it needs to build a different energy system, and the grid and storage that make any system usable. The order in which these are built matters as much as the total spent, and in our view the usual order is backwards.

Dependence moves, it does not disappear

India imports most of the crude oil it refines and a substantial share of its natural gas. Coal is largely domestic, but it carries its own constraints on emissions, rail capacity and quality. Every shock in a major oil-exporting region reaches Indian fuel prices, the current account and the fiscal arithmetic within weeks.

Electrification is the standard answer, and it is the right direction. It is also easy to oversell. Solar modules, cells and batteries depend on imported components and on processed minerals such as lithium, cobalt, nickel, graphite and rare earths, and the refining of many of these is concentrated in a small number of countries. Replacing an oil import bill with a battery and module import bill is progress on emissions. It is not, by itself, progress on security, because the chokepoint has simply moved upstream.

The buffers are thin. The Indian Strategic Petroleum Reserves Limited holds crude in underground caverns at Visakhapatnam, Mangaluru and Padur. That cushion is measured in days of consumption, not months, and it covers oil only. There is no comparable buffer for most of the minerals a modern grid and vehicle fleet will need.

Grid and storage come before more generation

Renewable capacity has been added quickly. The binding constraint is increasingly what happens after the panel: transmission to load centres, the ability to dispatch power after sunset, and the credit quality of the distribution companies that buy it. Projects have been commissioned and then waited for evacuation lines. The Green Energy Corridor programme exists to build these lines, and the Revamped Distribution Sector Scheme addresses distribution-company finances, but both are work in progress.

A gigawatt of solar that cannot reach a buyer, or can only sell in the middle of the day when supply is plentiful, earns less than its financial model assumed. Storage fixes part of this. Pumped hydro is mature and geographically limited. Battery storage is getting cheaper, and the government has offered viability gap funding to speed its first large deployments. Our view is that transmission and storage should be treated as the first build, not the follow-on, because they raise the value of every generation asset already in the ground.

Generation can be added in months; the grid that carries it and the storage that firms it take years, which is why they have to start first.

Hydrogen and minerals: build where the demand already exists

The National Green Hydrogen Mission, approved in 2023, supports electrolyser manufacturing and green hydrogen production through an incentive programme. The sensible reading of it is narrow. India already uses large amounts of hydrogen made from natural gas, in refineries and in fertiliser plants, and a good part of that gas is imported. Green hydrogen that displaces it saves foreign exchange from the first tonne. Hydrogen for trucks or aviation, by contrast, needs infrastructure and demand that do not exist yet. We would build for industrial offtake first and treat everything else as later.

The National Critical Mineral Mission, approved in 2025, covers exploration, processing, recycling and the acquisition of overseas assets. Khanij Bidesh India Limited, a joint venture of public sector companies, was set up to secure mineral assets abroad, and the 2023 amendment to the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act allowed auctions of critical mineral blocks. Auctions are a necessary step. They are not sufficient, because a mine without a domestic processing plant exports ore and leaves the value, and the dependence, elsewhere.

So the order we would argue for runs like this:

  • Transmission, evacuation and storage, so that existing and planned renewable capacity is fully usable.
  • Domestic manufacture of modules, cells and batteries, together with the processing of the minerals that feed them.
  • Green hydrogen and ammonia for refining and fertiliser, where demand is already there and imports are being displaced.
  • Recycling of batteries and electronics, which is a domestic mineral source that exists as soon as the first fleets age.
  • Overseas supply agreements and strategic stocks of the few minerals where concentration of supply is most extreme.

What we are watching

Two things will tell us whether the order is being followed. The first is the gap between renewable capacity commissioned and capacity actually evacuated and dispatched, which shows whether the grid is keeping up. The second is where mineral processing gets built, and by whom, relative to where mines are auctioned. If processing lags the auctions by a decade, India will have changed the label on its dependence and little else.

More from Media