Generational

Media

The cost of moving things: why logistics is India's quiet competitiveness lever

High logistics cost taxes Indian manufacturing before a product leaves the factory; corridors help, but terminals, warehousing and data decide the gain.

Logistics cost is a tax on Indian manufacturing that does not appear on any tax return. By most estimates it is a larger share of economic output than in the leading manufacturing economies, though the estimates differ by method and should be read as a direction, not a decimal. Cutting it will do more for export competitiveness than most tariff or subsidy changes, and much of the cost sits where policy attention is thinnest: in the first and last stretches of a consignment's trip.

Cost is only half the problem, predictability is the other

The freight rate per tonne-kilometre is the figure people quote. What a manufacturer actually experiences is variance. A consignment that takes three days one week and six the next forces the buyer to hold extra inventory, the seller to pad lead times, and the exporter to miss a vessel cut-off. These costs show up as working capital and lost orders, not as freight.

Road carries the largest share of freight, and rail a smaller share than its efficiency would justify. Trucks are cheap and flexible for short and mid distances, but the fleet is fragmented into very small operators, empty return trips are common, and checkpoints, loading and unloading and waiting at ports and terminals eat time. Dwell time at transfer points, where cargo changes mode, is often worse than the travel time between them.

What the state has built, and what it has not

The Dedicated Freight Corridors are the largest piece of physical capacity. The Eastern corridor runs from Punjab to West Bengal, and the Western from near Delhi to the Jawaharlal Nehru Port in Maharashtra, with the Western built to carry double-stacked container trains. By moving long-distance freight to its own tracks, they release capacity on the shared network for passenger services and let freight trains run faster and more reliably.

A corridor is only as useful as what connects to it. Freight has to reach a terminal, be loaded on to a train, and leave again at the other end for a customer. This is the work of multimodal logistics parks and rail cargo terminals, and the railways' Gati Shakti cargo terminal policy was created to let private operators build and run these. Terminals are the weakest link because they involve land, rail connections, road access and customs processes in a single place, and every one of those belongs to a different authority.

PM Gati Shakti, launched in 2021, tries to solve that coordination problem. It is a national master plan, with a geographic information platform on which ministries and states can layer their projects, so that a road is not planned without knowing where the rail line or the industrial cluster is. The National Logistics Policy of 2022 added a framework of targets and a commitment to simplify processes, and set up the Unified Logistics Interface Platform, which connects data held by different departments through standard interfaces.

Moving a tonne is cheap compared with moving it through three agencies, two terminals and one weekend.

We think the data layer may matter more than the concrete. If a consignment can be tracked across road, rail and port, and its documents can be checked once and not at every handover, dwell time falls without anyone pouring a new cubic metre of cement. The caution is that a platform with data but few users is a database. It becomes an operating system for logistics only when private operators build their tools on it.

Where private operators can add value

Public infrastructure sets the ceiling. Private operators decide how close the economy gets to it. A few areas stand out.

  • Terminals and parks that handle several modes, built next to freight corridors and managed as a service with published turnaround times.
  • Warehousing that is sized and located for the cargo it will actually hold. Warehousing was granted infrastructure status in 2017, and organised capacity is still a minority of the total.
  • Aggregation at the first mile, where thousands of small shippers and small trucks can be matched, reducing empty running and giving a small manufacturer access to rail.
  • Visibility software and financing built on shared data, so that a shipper can see where a container is and a lender can finance a consignment against it.
  • Cold chains and special handling for categories such as food and pharmaceuticals, where delay destroys value, not only time.

Our view is that the first and last miles are the underinvested end. The trunk routes attract capital because they are large, visible and easily financed, while the stretch from a factory gate or a farm to the first terminal is fragmented, informal and thin on margin. It is also where a rupee of improvement goes furthest, because every shipper in the country has to cross it.

The open question is whether the corridors will carry the cargo they were built for. Capacity does not move freight. Reliable, priced and tracked service does, and we are watching whether terminal operators and the railways can offer it at a level that makes a shipper change mode.

More from Media